Dealership Wants to Undo Used Car Sale Rather Than Make Promised Repairs
Dealership Wants to Undo Used Car Sale Rather Than Make Promised Repairs
Sophia DeRosiaThu, October 22, 2026 at 1:42 AM UTC
0
Photo Credit: Shixart1985 / Wikimedia
A used-car buyer says a dealership wants to cancel their purchase rather than complete repairs promised during the sale. The proposed solution would require the buyer to return their recently purchased vehicle and take back a trade-in that someone else had already bought and returned.
The disagreement started when a sales manager agreed in writing to fix several problems with the purchased vehicle. Two weeks later, the buyer says none of the promised work had been completed.
A follow-up with the dealership brought an unexpected response. The original sales manager no longer worked there, and the replacement manager reportedly suggested unwinding the transaction instead of completing the repairs.
Rather than accept the offer, the buyer turned to Reddit to ask whether the dealership could walk away from its commitments and whether taking the business to small claims court was a realistic option.
Promises Under Dispute
Dealership unwinding contractbyu/SaySorry inaskcarsales
In an October 9 Reddit post on r/askcarsales, the buyer explained that the former manager signed a separate promises page outlining the repairs. That signature also appeared on the other paperwork used to complete the sale.
The buyer also said the dealership promised additional work through text messages after another mechanical problem emerged shortly before delivery. The buyer said the issue had nearly caused them to refuse the vehicle.
Now, the dealership reportedly claims the signed promises page isn't binding because it doesn't include the dealership's name or logo.
The replacement manager also allegedly warned that the buyer would lose in small claims court and would need to sue the former employee personally.
Despite those warnings, the buyer remained unwilling to reverse the purchase, particularly given what had happened to the original trade-in.
Advertisement
Reddit Pushes Back
Responses ranged from recommending a clean break with the dealership to encouraging the buyer to pursue the unfinished repairs.
One commenter suggested obtaining estimates from another dealership of the same brand and an independent repair shop. Those estimates could show how much money would be needed to complete the work if the dispute went to court.
Others questioned the dealership's reported legal position, arguing that an employee's departure doesn't automatically eliminate commitments made on behalf of the business. However, the dealership did not share the paperwork, leaving important questions about the agreement unanswered.
Not everyone thought a lawsuit was worthwhile. Some suggested returning the purchased vehicle and shopping elsewhere rather than spending additional time fighting over repairs.
That option raised another concern: the buyer's old vehicle had already been in someone else's possession. Several commenters questioned why the buyer should accept it back without knowing what happened while the second customer owned it.
What Happens Next
The Reddit post was labeled as a Canadian sale, but the buyer did not identify the province. Contract remedies and consumer-protection procedures can differ depending on where the purchase occurred.
Written repair commitments, text messages, and independent repair estimates could all become relevant if the buyer pursues the dispute. Whether those materials create an enforceable obligation depends on the agreement and applicable law.
The buyer did not identify the dealership or vehicle, and did not specify which repairs remained unfinished or how much they would cost.
As of the discussion, no court action or settlement had been confirmed. The buyer had rejected the dealership's proposal and was still seeking advice about pursuing the promised work.
Source: “AOL Money”
